Shona
Winfrey
Reviews:
December,
2004
Scroll
down for the latest release by Elliott Smith, Soulwax, Fatboy
Slim, The Charlatans and The Undoing
Elliott Smith
From a Basement On the Hill
(ANTI)
www.anti.com
Autumn, 2004
Posthumously Eloquent, Dignified
Elegant
Elliott Smiths death, whatever circumstance
surrounds it---and I dont
know but the barest gossip, because I never went back to try
and find
out, it seemed so intrusive to wonder about something so much
not my
business---has been a tragedy of enormous proportion for many,
many
people, least including people like me, who listened to him,
and waited.
I was waiting for another album six months after Figure
8 was
released in 2000. His death is a waste to me; a waste of his
tremendous talent, a waste of his life, which always appeared
to verge
on falling apart. I thought, and sometimes said, that anyone
who
sounded like he did, like an angel, even in the most un-angelic
moments
of his music, was not long for this world.
I could be judged a very poor fan advertisement
for Smith. His music
snuck up on me, then hit me like a ton of bricks quite suddenly,
all at
once, after Id been vaguely listening to it for months,
and probably
not hearing it. After this epiphany, there followed a time
when
Either/Or and XO rotated through my CD player
on a daily basis for
months.
There was a time when I resigned myself to listen to his Kill
Rock Stars
indie debut, and to Roman Candle, and did so---with
a scowl on my
face. There was a time when I went to his gigs every time
he came
through town, where I lay around on the floor to listen to
him, as if I
couldnt be bothered to give him my attention. Actually,
Im certain I
paid more attention to his music at his gigs than I did anyone
elses
during their live performances. Once, he actually addressed
the
audience and chuckled about something, and I had to get up
off a
carpeted area near the back of the Black Cat to look. He performed
Happiness later, and it stuck in my head, like
a rhyme from childhood,
where it played over and over for a very long time. Smiths
songs were
riveting, even live. When the album bearing it was released,
I spent an
entire afternoon running from store to store to store one
Tuesday to buy
it.
When Elliott Smiths most recent, and
probably last, record was
released, I didnt run after it. Hed been dead
a year, I couldnt
bring myself to play my old CDs, and I was fearful, as always,
when a
band or artist that I love releases a new record, that Id
be let down.
It was so easy to expect this to be hyped. The cynic in me
believed it
would fall far short of anything Id come to expect myself,
or read or
heard from anyone else.
Its honestly tragic then, to find From
a Basement On the Hill to be
the most accomplished , or at least the most eclectic mix
of, material
he ever did; his swan song is his White Album. Always and
ever
Beatlesesque, this finds him hauntingly, achingly reminiscent
of Lennon
and Harrison. And finally, far more introspective than anything
he did
before. Occasionally, theres almost enough emotion in
the delivery to
make good on the lyrical content. In hindsight, of course,
more musical
display of anger and less self-loathing may have been in order.
The recording itself is half-finished. Some
tracks are fleshed out and
polished affairs, like the near-maudlin Twilight
and Pretty (Ugly
Before), or the accusatory opener, Coast to Coast,
weirdly punctuated
by someone reading poetry rife with pseudo-religious imagery.
As such,
they offer no real surprises except in how candid Smiths
lyrics had
become and as such, the sense that there was a lot more wrong
in his
world than he was able or willing to expose previously.
What was likely to shock those fans of Smith
who knew and loved his work
via material like that found on XO and Figure 8
are the musical
paths hed started to wander, evidenced by tracks like
Dont Go Down:
no pretty ballad, this. Its more an electrified tale
of reprobation
and salvation with a load of seventies era guitar hijinks
thrown on
board to make a point. Like the much-clichéd
Little Wing before it,
its a story of the (in this case) abused, crazy-girl---hard
and
cracked as the Liberty Bell to quote Smiths own
lyrics--- turned
angel, bringing redemption to the vilified junkie.
Itd be unfair not to suggest that listening
Smith unload his
self-loathing might get boring. If anyone else did the same,
it could
be taken as self-indulgent whining. Here, though, it only
underlines
his ability to pen often florid, always vivid lyrics showing
the
horrible prescience he had about his impending death. Of little
consolation is the soul-baring of A Fond Farewell,
A Passing
Feeling, and particularly of Strung Out Again
which are honestly
depressing. The latter is truly a vision of emotional squalor.
That
these songs are liable to make one think of George Harrisons
guitar
every chorus and bridge doesnt make them any easier
to take. And to
the end, tracks like the closing A Distorted Reality
Has Become a
Necessity to Live, which seems to be missing a verse
or two, reveal his
artistic progression enough to start the What if?
cycle of wonder.
Discussing the album with another fan of
Smiths, himself a musician, a
friend admitted he was having trouble with the record. He
prefers
Elliott Smith albums all cool and smooth and slick.
*Not*, probably,
the totally off-kilter, wildly screeching goings-on of Shooting
Star.
Retro, this is for all the world a glammed up anthem of some
sort, were
it seen to a well-produced end. Its also one of those
playing tricks
with my mind songs, thanks in no small part to the lyrics.
For those
of a chaste disposition, its probably about a woman.
For the knowing
and/or more theatrical/imaginative of us, its a first-class
drug song.
It even sounds druggy: paranoid, remorseful then remorseless,
utterly
confused and confusing. Shooting Star rattles
on of its own accord,
and at times, sounds like one more hit, one more shot would
find the
underlying and barely constructed swagger---hanging on by
sheer force of
will---collapse on itself into total cacophony. Its
chaos as narcotic
oblivion, delivered by guitars and drums. Yet another instance
of not
pretty, its also one of the most affecting tracks.
Strangely, or perhaps not, its just the kind
of thing on this record
that has made me feel acutely bad, all over again, that Elliott
Smith
died. Kings Crossing, was the song here
that really captured my
attention and alerted me to how different a direction he was
going. A
tragi-comic piece about addiction and dying, who or what it
was about
will become irrelevant. Filled with swirling keyboards that
supply a
carnival-like atmosphere and nearly poetic imagery, it can
stand on its
own for what it is: a brilliant piece of musical psychedelia.
Those responsible for compiling the album
could have been emotionally
manipulative and placed The Last Hour as the final
track, but they
didnt. They didnt need to.
This album is what it is: amazing, and unfortunately, very
sad in an
all too real and tangible way.
_______________________________________________________________
Soulwax
Any Minute Now
PIAS Recordings
www.pias.com
Dance Tunes for
Dweebs, and Guitar Pop Lovers
Soulwaxs third album as a rock (RAWK)
band finds this Belgian band
sounding very dancey. Indeed, the first song, E Talking,
has a very
dancey, Just Say NO kinda video that is, well,
comical. That said,
both it and the title track will appease fans hungry for more
of 1999s
Much Against Everyones Advice, but the tracks
following are liable,
honestly, to aggravate. Part of this record rocks and rolls.
What
doesnt and is in between, snakes around, grooving over
an electronic
beat, bleeps,beeps, zips and zaps. This could ostensibly make
it an
easier task to mix the songs for the DeWaeles (the Soulwax
siblings)
side project, TwoManyDJs. It could also make indie or power-pop
(ugh!
that term again!) fans have a fit.
Then again
Compute, track
four, grows spectacularly sing-along, and
has some seriously heavy, crunchin guitars to offset
that groovy
dance-able beat. It makes me giddy. Following, find KracK,
a tune
that sounds an awful lot like something that fell off fellow
countrymen/rock star outfit Millionaires album from
a couple years
back, what with that totally scary, Texas-chainsaw-massacre
guitar
noise. This leads to more sugar/testosterone buzzing with
the
near-perfect, brilliant Slowdance, boasting
clever lyrics like Play
the sequence in your head, embrace the fact youre someone
else. This
might be about being thrown in the moshpit, but it could be
about
playing video games or sex games or not saying no to chemicals.
Its
hard to tell what the hell is happening, what with a girl
screaming on
the intro and the break, with them going on about not being
able to make
connections. Like the best material from the last album, its
atmospheric and grand to the point of distraction, discounting
the
freakin beat underneath.
True to form, the mid-section of the album
is filled out with a couple
of slow numbers, including the sweeping, orchestral grandeur
of
Accidents and Compliments, very much on par with
MAEAs Proverbial
Pants and The Salty Knowledge of Tears.
Itd be a lie to suggest
that this isnt a bit deflating after the high of the
previous few
tracks bent to hyperkinesis. The trade? A person would
have to be
illiterate not to love the phrases Soulwax turn then throw
around in
their lyrics: you need truth and aspirin, I need violence
and the
smirking I need pills and memories, you need an audience,
built up
over the dreamy soundscape, turning it ever so slightly subversive
and
toward the nightmarish.
There is, however, no excuse for the annoying,
obnoxious NY Excuse.
Had it gone on thusly, this would now be a platter for serving
cat food.
Miserable Girl, built on a keyboard loop, takes
off on its own
buzzing guitars and sense of humor before it morphs into the
ultra-glammy YYY/NNN, by stealing the beat from
Rock and Roll, part
II, no less.
Unfortunately, the final track shows off
misplaced aspirations at
prog-rock, loses its sense of humor and eventually, the album
wafts off
into the thin air with a strange electronic/ambient reprise
of
Slowdance called Dance 2 Slow. They
shouldve sent if off with a
big bang of some sort, and kept that rush going. It would
have meant
the difference between a good album and a very good one. Tsk.
Available as import.
________________________________________________________________
Fatboy Slim
Palookaville
Skint Records
www.astralwerks.com
Songs from the Great Radio Graveyard of the Mind
By Shona Winfrey
Though it begins as less than classic, and
the start up is somewhat
bumpy, by track three, this becomes recognizable as something
of a true
Gold Star, or four, or five, or an A+, depending on where
youre doing
your thinking.
The genius of this album, pure and simple,
is that Norman Cook, via his
alter ego, finally managed to do what he set about doing with
From the
Gutter to the Stars: he has stuffed the spirit and life
force of a
1970s era, American AM car radio onto one single album.
It doesnt matter one whit that resources
and inspirations as disparate
as beatnik poets and Latin dance music are sharing the ride
with 80s
house and 90s trip hop, and that his cake has been frosted
with an
ongoing computer-enhanced wackiness all around. It matters
not that
rappers are in league with pompous, hyperbolic rock lyrics,
or that he
tops it off with a cover of Steve Millers The
Joker, sang by funk
bassmeister Bootsy Collins.
I could break this thing apart track by track,
but that would be
pointless. Fatboy Slim fans jonesing for more Better Living
Through
Chemistry and Youve Come A Long Way, Baby
big-beats techno may be in
for a shocking disappointment. It wasnt what I expected,
and it sure
as hell wasnt what I wanted when I bought it and brought
it home.
Its driven me crazy, trying to place samples, and creating
false
memories from songs Id never heard before, yet swore
Id known most of
my life. Anyone willing to stick it out with this very eclectic,
funny,
brilliant record---anyone with an open mind, anyone who loves
music in
all its color and variety---will find it growing on her/him.
Heres why: there are gems here, like
Put It Back Together by Cook and
Damon Albarn, delivered in what can only be described as a
stoned
demeanor by the latter, able to fool this writer and others
with a
decent recall of music and a large library of records to pull
from, into
believing wed known it from the recesses of our collective
childhood
minds. Albarn squeals Put this back together, yeah-yeah-yeah!
in
falsetto on the chorus, backup singer gleefully going one
better,
instantly transforming it to a classic Philly soul sound-alike,
however
silly.
In Wonderful Night, a Brit-centric
rap alternates very energetically
about partying, chatting up a girl and what must be my
posse and your
posse, over an infectious dance beat. No big-beats,
just a dance beat.
In Long Way From Home, a tinny guitar and over-amped
bass vie for
attention with a spoken word monologue about some rather paraonoid
guy
getting a ride. The chorus is a rock song, there are snippets
of some
acid jazz song *I know from somewhere* holding the mess together.
Does
it work? Were there ever inflatable pigs flying at Pink Floyd
concerts?
North West Three, with an endless loop of Primrose
Hill; Push
and Shove with its mid-70s, hyper-serious, utterly ridiculous
lyrics,
broken up by a joke or two. The Journey, part
cowboy song, part urban
poetry. The utterly trippy-ambient, Latin-flavored Song
for Chesh
Eventually, the game of Whats
What and Whos Who loses out to plain
old infectiousness. It will remain indescribable. Not a techno
record,
not a dance record, just a lasting testament to Norman Cooks
career as
Fatboy Slim, and how he continues to make music, breaking
his own rules,
not becoming formulaic.
_______________________________________________________________
The Charlatans
Up At the Lake
Universal-MCA (UK)
www.islandrecords.co.uk
The Undoing
The Charlatans are revered in the UK as being
the Manchester band from
that esteemed era of the very late 1980s-very early
1990s whove
proven themselves through sheer longevity, if not adaptability.
Their
undoing couldve been the truly untimely death of keyboardist
Rob
Collins back in 1995. They stuck it out, though, bringing
Tony Rogers
over from Primal Scream, to carry on in Collins stead.
Collins and his
wailing Hammond organ, really the bands signature, went
sorely missing
though, and things have grown ever-spottier.
One moment, they were Stonesy, at another
turn, Who-like. Now,
unfortunately, they appear to be morphing into a band who
cant find
themselves or define their sound. Up At the Lake, starting
with its
title track, gets off to a promising lead. Then, the Charlatans
go
through paces: a hybrid of their early selves and mid-80s
Rolling
Stones to rootsy bar band to maudlin balladeers. And this
in the space
of four songs.
It isnt as if the Charlies are a bad
band---oh fk no. Tight as ever,
over again, they are masterful players, above adequate singers.
The
record isnt even bad or mediocre, but the fire seems
to be definitely
out. They are still capable of beating the hell out of most
junk found
on US radio, where long strings of anonymous Pearl Jam and
Soundgarden
clones play kick the can with the latest crop of Korn or Limp
Bizkit
wannabes, when the airwaves arent being held hostage
by little boy
bands with bad attitude like Blink 182 or Good
Charlotte. Id thrill
to find the player-piano, good times are rolling of Bona
Fide Treasure
or the hooky-chiming guitars of Blue for You on
the radio.
Nevertheless, with this album, I have to
admit Id kill for the kicks
this band used to provide with songs like Polar Bear,
or for something
with the the strange, depressed groove of Cant
Even Be Bothered in
tandem with the manic Weirdo. Going back over
their catalog, I find
that even after Collins demise and departure from the
band, they had
some truly illustrious moments, up to and including some of
2001s
Wonderland Avenue like the addictive track, Judas.
Up At the Lake finds them saddle with
ballads and mid-tempo pop
outings, including one co-penned by Linus of Hollywood. I
dont object
to pop songs, but the Charlatans? They were an acid guitar
band,
bested, honestly, only by the Stone Roses when they were at
their very
best. Now, theyre just like the rest of us: moved to
the burbs, got
a house, got in a relationship with a capital R, and literally,
sound
like theyve been trapped by their trappings.
Ever-popular vocalist and frontman Tim Burgess
said in an interview that
he moved to LA because he felt his whole life like the sky
was on his
head in northern and middle England. Im beginning to
think that the
wide open spaces, fresh air and sunshine have addled his senses.
This may be the Charlatans undoing. It sure sounds like it.
_____________________________________________________________
To
reach any other page contained in this month's update on Fufkin.com,
read the home page for the appropriate link and click on it.
You can also search the site from any page using the search
box located at the top of each page. Merely type in the word,
phrase, name of the band, recording, name of the Fufkin writer
that you are looking for or Whatever in the search box, and
then click on "Search". If you would like to e-mail
us, go to the About Us page for a list of e-mail addresses.
Go
back to the home page by clicking
here
________________________________________________________________
|