Shona Winfrey
Reviews: June, 2001
Scroll
down for Weezers review
The Posies
Nice Cheekbones And A PhD - EP
(Houston Party)
www.theposies.com
But When They Are Good, They Are Very, Very Good
I feel like I should make some kind of qualifying statement before I say
how underwhelmed I was and remain with this release. (All good Sloan fans
will applaud my use of this non-existent word, and all English majors
and professors reading this review will surely point out that underwhelmed
isn't a word at all, but disappointed sounds too harsh).
So to qualify the statements I'm about to make, let me say that I've always
been of the opinion that anything Ken Stringfellow or Jon Auer (or any
combination thereof ) which either or both happen to come into contact
with is the equivalent of pop music manna from heaven. And it isn't even
that this is a bad little collection. It's just that well, it sounds not
so much like the Posies, as like Jon and Ken. Meaning: Jon did a song,
then Ken did a song, and so on. And much of the time, the EP sounds not
quite finished, as if a particular song made it to demo stage and was
recorded and released. Birthed like a premature baby, a bit before, perhaps,
it was quite ready to see the light of day. Aside from "Matinee", the
lead track (a contribution from Stringfellow) the work seems largely like
a group of songs still in infancy, rather than something fully realized
and executed to fullest potential, It's not that the EP lacks hooks---"Chainsmoking
In the USA" has a great, hooky chorus. But the songs never seem to kick
in or climax and are lacking crunch. And crunch is good. From the Posies,
crunch is practically expected.
That
said, fans who never recovered when the Posies departed from the pure
pop sound of *Dear 23* are going to be elated. In fact, the coda to "With
Those Eyes" sounds like the long-lost stolen closing notes from that album's
"Any Other Way". For those of us who really got hung up on this band because
of Frosting on the Beater and Amazing Disgrace and the real
kicking power behind the pop, there may be some minor deflation in store.
I very much preferred Stringfellow gone solo with Saltine and think Auer's
The Perfect Size EP to be one of the past year's real can't-live-without
essential releases for pop/power pop enthusiasts (that's a really beautiful
little record which garnered barely any attention, oddly enough).
Still,
there are amazing moments here. On "Matinee", Ken hits high notes that
had the hair on the nape of my neck standing on end. And whenever these
two sing together, the harmony is the same as it ever was,. One thing
remains plain: separate or combined, they can sing like nobody's business,
and have two of the flat out prettiest voices in the history of popular
music. (This is no overstatement from a rabidly zealous fan, either).
Their take on the David Crosby penned song, the Byrds' "Lady Friend" ,
for the closer of this release is an absolute stunner. They sound gorgeous
together, and it's breathtaking. Shame they couldn't have done it for
the entire five-song duration. Perhaps this is an indicator of future
collaboration. We should all continue to live in hope.
__________________________________________________
Weezer
Weezer
Interscope Records/Geffen
www.weezer.com
Released May 15, 2001
There *IS* A Cure For The Summertime Blues… (and
it has a green cover)
This
is a really unprofessional, very personal and deeply heartfelt, hence
not the least bit objective, opening for a record review. I love Weezer.
I reiterate: I LOVE Weezer. I love the band so much that I've been
a card-carrying member of the Weezer fanclub. I was way too old, but I
did it anyway. I worked with people during the time that "Buddy Holly"
was a hit who swore up and down that they'd think of me for the rest of
their lives every time and any time they heard that or "Undone (The Sweater
Song)". I had terminology in my speech based on Weezerisms and Weezerishness.
I have at times felt Weezeresque. I had tickets to see them on their latest
tour, got them four months in advance, and I was so ill that I could not
go. I cried for a week. Big tears. And I'm a grown woman raising a child.
Folks, this was true pathos. Was I happy to get my sweaty little paws
on this disc? Did pigs ever fly at Pink Floyd concerts?
People have been split down the middle about the reappearance of this
band on the music scene. Weezer've got former Car Ric Ocasek back in the
producer's seat, leading to speculation that the band can't go it alone,
having tried and failed. There's been a lot of sniping about how short
the record is (it clocks in at around thirty minutes or so, I guess---I
haven't gotten the egg timer out and checked). Someone started carrying
on about how all the songs on it sound alike (some do, some don't). Then
there are detractors who are bitching about how the quality of the songwriting
has suffered (ostensibly because frontman Rivers Cuomo is out to make
a fast buck off his quick fix hit record, which isn't "deep", like 1996's
*Pinkerton* which sold like six hundred copies worldwide because there
were only six hundred music fans in the entire universe who understood
it, because it was the rock and roll equivalent of "Madame Butterfly",
and moreover, it didn't spawn a bunch of really cool videos on empty-vee---no,
really).
For the record, I don't watch TV much, and I don't have cable, so I don't
know about videos for either *Pinkerton* or the latest eponymously titled
offering. Further, I thought, apparently stupidly, that Pinkerton
was a great pop record and played it nearly as much as Weezer's other
self-tilted album released back in 1994. And this one? Oh my heavenly
stars----this is something wonderful.
Think
of ten songs, all of them ripe to bursting point with perfect hooks and
clocking in at just under three minutes average. Now imagine that all
the songs are bouncy in a hip-shaking, shoulder-shimmying, head-nodding
kinda way and overlaid with a lot of crunchy guitar and fuzzy bass and
a teeny tiny hint of some reverb, and just packed whompin' full of heaps
of sugar buzz and sunshine.
Basically,
the record is the audio equivalent of drinking Orange Crush at the beach
when you were a twelve year old and members of the opposite sex were interesting
in a vague way, but not as much fun as the tilt-a-whirl or the Monkees'
song being blasted over the PA system at the carnival.
This
album was invented for summer. It will doubtless serve as someone's soundtrack
to an essay on "How I Spent My Summer Vacation" next fall.
Is
it missing the old angst? Yes, it is. Does that matter? Probably not.
Wasn't Cuomo's brand of lyrical angst always slightly humorous anyway?
Wasn't that why we related to it in the first place? Is the songwriting
suffering? No, not really. The songs do feel short and in comparison to
what Cuomo and Weezer have done before, they do seem simple. Strangely
enough, for this, they come off sounding fresh and bubbly---pristinely
poppy.
It's
understandable that there'd be complaints about length, because the record's
so good and so damned much fun that it doesn't seem like enough, but a
half hour of "really good" is always better than an hour in which half
is spent hitting the forward skip on the CD player. Technology does have
"repeat". Don't wear it out.
Best pick of the lot: not a bummer amongst them, but the stand out is
"Island In The Sun", which comes right after the locomotive chug-chugging
of the single "Hash Pipe", a song that will doubtless go down in history
for driving the censors at the FCC round the bend once and for all.
Biggest question after repeated listenings: since when has any Yank ever
referred to female undergarments as "knickers" any time in the past century?
Piece of advice: buy it, play it, love it.
__________________________________________________
To
reach any other page on Fufkin.com, read the home page for the appropriate
link and click on it. You can also search the site by typing in the name
of the band, recording or name of the Fufkin writer that you are looking
for in the search box, and then click on search.
Go
back to the home page by clicking here
|