Jason Thompson Reviews: July, 2001
Scroll
down for Greg Trooper, Patti Rothberg and Amanda Thorpe
Scott Miller & the Commonwealth
Thus Always to Tyrants
(Sugar
Hill)
Being
from the Knoxville, TN area, it's always pretty big news whenever
a local band gets a major label deal. And so it was with much
anticipation that the local crowds held their breath when
such bands as the Judybats, Superdrag, and the V-Roys sallied
forth into the Big Time. Since then, the Judybats have come
and gone and come back again, Superdrag recently released
their second major label album, and the V-Roys finally called
it quits after three albums on New Year's Eve 2000. Personally,
I liked the V-Roys the best out of these bands, and saw them
rock the house down when they opened for Cheap Trick at Moose's
Music Lounge in Knoxville. It was standing room only and both
bands came out and kicked the shit out of everyone.
So
it is with much pleasure that I can announce former V-Roy
Scott Miller's solo career. His latest disc with new band
the Commonwealth, Thus Always to Tyrants is being released
on June 12, 2001 on the Sugar Hill imprint, a label that houses
such greats as Chet Atkins, Clarence Gatemouth Brown, Dolly
Parton, and Doc Watson to name a few. For both new fans and
old V-Roys stalwarts, Scott Miller's new album is pure bliss.
When
I first got this disc, I kind of put in blindly, having pulled
it out of the giant stack of CDs that comes my way for review
every so often. As soon as the first song "Across the
Line" kicked in I thought to myself, "Damn this
sounds like the V-Roys!" So when I finally took the time
to look at the sleeve and see Miller's name emblazoned across
the front of it, I smacked myself in the head and a great
sense of duhsville enveloped me. Needless to say, I was happy
to hear Miller again, having been not quite sure what he had
been up to after the big break. So I am happy to report that
Scott is still kicking up the same great patch of dirt with
his unique brand of rootsy rockabilly that he's been treating
us to all these years.
There's
twelve tracks here, and each of them sparkle with a great
raw sensibility that is clearly Miller's own. Whether he's
rocking it up religiously on "I Made a Mess of This Town",
or turning in a folk/country/bluegrass hybrid in "Dear
Sarah", each tune shines throughout. Scott's familiar
biting wit also crops up in "I Won't Go With You"
(which supports one of those great Miller riffs that will
get stuck in your head long after) and "Goddamn the Sun",
an under two minute piece of crunchy rock perfection with
solid harmonies and fantastic guitar that could have gone
on for another four minutes and not become tiresome.
Miller's
southern heritage rears its head in "Highland County
Boy" and "Daddy Raised a Boy". But where this
kind of territory often dips into corny nostalgia when handled
by the pop confectioners in Nashville, Scott pushes these
tunes across as sure and earnest as someone with this much
genuine talent can. Whether singing the plaintive and simple
"Is There Room on the Cross for Me" or locking down
the swamp grooves of "Miracle Man", Miller has all
his bases covered with nary a note unchecked. This music is
good and loose as it should be, but tight enough to convert
the unbelievers.
That
being said, Scott Miller should very well indeed have a bright
future on the great musical horizon to look forward to. Keeping
true to his own vision has always been part of the process,
and he faithfully continues that practice here on Thus
Always to Tyrants. So if you're a fan of that old V-Roys
sound, or just need something new and different to listen
to that rocks just as good as it rolls, then please be sure
to give this one a spin. Scott Miller & the Commonwealth
are just getting started, after all. It's surely going to
be interesting to see what they have in store for the future
if the present is already sounding this good.
__________________________________________________
Greg
Trooper
Straight
Down Rain
(Eminent)
The
cover photo of Straight Down Rain shows Greg Trooper
in a moment of anguish, sitting at his kitchen table with
face hidden behind his hand. Throughout the disc's booklet,
there's a set of similar sepia-toned shots with Trooper looking
pensive. In one photo, he looks like a scared cat backed into
a corner, wary of your presence and perhaps ready to strike.
I suppose you could say the same thing about his music. It's
laden with folksy despair, a good amount of angst, and a bit
of bitter humor.
"I've
got more fear than wisdom/I've got fences to mend/You've got
an ocean of reasons/To let this chapter end" sings Trooper
on the opening cut "Nothin' But You". That sense
of loss creeps over a lot of this album. "I shot the
moon to reach the sun/Thought I was the only one/Found a deeper
shade of blue/Nothing out here compares to you". Poignant
to the point of being able to feel Trooper's pain, the song
ends with "I thought I had to take it alone/Now I'm racing
back to find you/With every reason to believe I'll find you
gone".
Elsewhere,
Trooper tries to mend a damaged relationship in "You
Love Your Broken Heart" and conjures up his own brand
of folklore in "Damaged Eyes", a song about "poor
misguided Annabelle". Consider it this year's "Marie
Provost" with slightly less bite. But Trooper does have
a lighter side, as he knocks himself in "Once And For
All": "Once and for all/Please don't look at me/Like
you're appalled/At my shiverin' and shakin' knees". "Doghouse"
has a similar feel to it, albeit one that has been researched
time and time again by other artists who have hit the occasional
corny note. "I'm in the dog house now/She says don't
make me call the cops, this is where your love boat stops/Your
gravy train's run out of grease, the love we had is now deceased".
Take that for what you will, but I have to admit it incited
more than one groan.
And
while Trooper continues to picture himself as a "criminal"
in such tunes as "Staring Down The Night", he celebrates
love when he has found it with equal aplomb in such numbers
as "Real Like That" and "Over The Moon".
Greg also paints the familiar pictures of how hard it is to
keep a love going strong in "Lovin' Never Came That Easy",
and stops to offer social commentary on crime and abuse in
"Sometimes It Takes A Hurricane". Trooper is an
Everyman storyteller, one who covers a wide range of topics
and subtleties that the working man can relate to.
While
it does hit the occasional moon/June/spoon snag in the lyrics,
Trooper does a fine job of handling his songs and subject
matter. Basically, he is a bright light shining out of what
can often be a most turgid Nashville scene, one filled with
prefabricated good lookin' cowboys and songs that could have
been conceived by a three year old. Such is not the case here
on Straight Down Rain, an album filled with straight
shooting, from the heart sentiments that feel genuine through
and through. Greg Trooper certainly is an artist with style
and enough talent to back up his vivid lyrics and down to
earth playing. A sure breath of fresh air in an increasingly
stagnant climate.
___________________________________________________
Patti
Rothberg
Candelabra
Cadabra
(Cropduster)
Once
in a blue moon, an album arrives on the shelves that literally
defies all categorization. I genuinely prize such works when
they come my way. Most often I have found that these albums
are usually products of the female persuasion. Such items
that come to mind are Area's fragments of the morning
and Milla's The Divine Comedy. Well it's time to add
another spectacular addition to the list. Ladies and gentlemen,
I present to you Patti Rothberg's Candelabra Cadabra.
You
may recall that Rothberg had a debut on the EMI America label
back in 1996 called Between the 1 and 9 that received
numerous raves. Unfortunately, Patti's big label folded shortly
after her release leaving her to her own devices for a short
time. Now she's back on Cropduster with a new set of material
that for all intents and purposes is strictly magical. And
that's not really an adjective that I'd ever dreamed of using
in a record review before now.
Hearing
Rothberg's music is like opening a giant story book filled
with enormous and colorful illustrations and diving in head
first. Or maybe it's like an old lost book of spells that
is at once both enchanting and ominous. Either way, this is
the stuff dreams are made of. The dreams you have when you're
deep asleep in the dark late at night. The dreams that sparkle
and fade, gently pulling you awake in the morning. With Patti,
everything is very grand. She paints minutiae with wide brush
strokes that color your own imagination and keep you seeking
more within her melodies.
Opening
with the outstanding "Nothing I Can Say" with its
powerful and crunchy guitars and hand claps, Candelabra
Cadabra begins its journey on a somewhat familiar love-inspired
tale. But from there, things turn a bit strange. The title
track is downright spellbinding with its other-worldly flavors
and heightened sense of drama, and in "Delicate Matters"
Rothberg pays tribute to the Doors via "The End".
But where Jim Morrison always had to push things over with
his bravado and ultimately send his band into faux and often
embarrassing noir territory, Patti's chorus for the song manages
to scale even higher mountains than the ones created by the
already lofty verses. It's intense and strangely beautiful.
Eastern
influences paint the travelogue from the pillow "Shadows
Of Me", and in "You Killed My Time" Rothberg
sits quietly with her guitar, finally bringing the larger
than life atmosphere of the album down to earth. But just
as she does that, she splits the sky wide open with her coda
that sends shimmering waves of electric guitars over the listener,
bathing the eardrums once again with her stylized psychedelia.
Where does this stuff come from? How can mere words do it
justice?
"Preyed
Upon" is so adamantly intense that its grandeur almost
swallows it up. "Eggshells" defies lyrical convention
with its odd array of story telling and details. I get images
of the movie Blow-Up in my head when I hear it, if
that tells you anything. But the most precious gem Rothberg
offers here is undoubtedly "To A Muse". If ever
there was a great lost power pop/new wave tune, then this
is it. Filled with ungodly amazing hooks, Patti's beautiful
voice and even some funky Moog lines, "To A Muse"
is worth the price of admission alone. You miss out on this
one song, I guarantee you've missed out on one of the best
songs that are going to be released this year. And if that's
not enough, then dig the funky pumps of "Dish It Out"
which sounds more than radio ready.
I
can't give all of the fantastic tales of Candelabra Cadabra
away. So I will leave it up to you to seek Patti Rothberg
out and immerse yourself in the final tracks of the album
(the cover of Bowie's "Moonage Daydream", "Suffocator",
"The Late Late Show", and "The Wry It Girl").
This album is already tagged for inclusion on my Best of 2001
list, so great it is that I am often rendered speechless after
hearing it. Amazing that I managed to get this much out about
it already. Thank Cropduster for giving us another amazing
album. Thank Patti Rothberg for being so amazingly talented.
Forget Tori Amos and her faerie land. Rothberg is the real
deal.
___________________________________________________
Amanda
Thorpe
Mass
(Cropduster)
Please
note: AMANDA THORPE IS NOT A FOLKIE. She would like you to
know that. She would like you to know that she is a rocker.
Or course, she bent my ear about this fact after my review
for Mass had already been submitted to PopMatters.
But at the time I wrote it, I didn't know that. I mean, I
loved her music but her bio and other stuff I read about her
said this and that about trip hop and that and this about
folk. So when you haven't heard from the person yourself and
you have their disc playing in your stereo and seeking additional
information that may or may not be true, you do your best.
Well,
Amanda did like the review ("Even though you labeled
me as a folkie!" she cried.) Oh I didn't label her that
at all. I said the folk ties were strong, and called Mass
the Hejira for my generation. I still think that suits
it well, but I admit she is more rock and roll than anything
folkie I've ever known. So over the course of conducting a
long and still on-going interview as of this writing, I have
got to know Amanda from a person to person point of view and
not a press kit to critic angle. It's been lovely and Amanda
has a great sense of humor and is wonderful to chat with.
So
if you want to know about her great album Mass, I could
just redirect you to my former review and say have a look
at that. But at the same time, perhaps I'd like to add more
to that. More to the fact that her version of "Them There
Eyes" is something you just have to hear. More
about how "Splinters" still gives me goosebumps
and how "This Dear City" is perfect through and
through. Basically kids, I just want you to go out and get
this album and really listen to it. Before I name-dropped
Aimee Mann and Fiona Apple when discussing Amanda. If you
like them, you'll love this. And if you're familiar with the
group The Wirebirds, then you're one step ahead of the game
already as Amanda cut her chops with them not so long ago.
She'd
like you to know that she doesn't play "Frances"
or "Hymn" live. She'd like to say that she was once
from the UK but took a visit to our shores and found them
so pleasing that she decided to stay in New York and be the
rock and roll girl that she is. She'd like to let you know
more, but for that you'll have to wait for our conversation
to actually wind down and then actually appear online. Which
it will. In the meantime, you can listen to "High &
Dry" and curse the FM or get swept away with "By
You" and "Always". You do recall that I mentioned
trip hop? Amanda would like you to know that that isn't necessarily
the case either. ("Laced with would be correct.")
Well you know biographers and their need to describe.
Amanda
Thorpe is Amanda Thorpe. She makes her own sounds and says
that her friends tell her her music's great but that she doesn't
have an obvious single. In an album like Mass, that
hardly matters. Works like these do not require the hit single
to propel them. This is a complete album that begs of you
to sit down and listen to it. If you need the single, then
perhaps you should look elsewhere. But if you do, then you
chose to miss out. You chose to walk away from a beautiful
piece of music that you're not going to find anywhere else.
So that's all I have to say. Amanda Thorpe on Cropduster with
her beautiful new album Mass. It's that simple. And
Amanda really is rock and roll. Bless her soul.
__________________________________________________
To
reach any other page on Fufkin.com, read the home page for
the appropriate link and click on it. You can also search
the site by typing in the name of the band, recording or name
of the Fufkin writer that you are looking for in the search
box, and then click on search. If you would like to e-mail
us, go to the About Us page for a list of e-mail addresses.
Go
back to the home page by clicking
here
__________________________________________________
|