Mike
Bennett
Reviews,
Part II:
May,
2002
Scroll
down for reviews of the latest from Clinic, Ben Kweller, The
Mooney Suzuki and Kenny Howes and The Yeah.
Click here for the reviews
of the latest from Toothpaste 2000, Brendan
Benson, Gomez and Shy Nobleman.
XTC
A Coat Of Many Cupboards
(Virgin)
xtcidearecords.co.uk
If
you're looking for the definitive box set for XTC, the one
that you can buy for friends as an aural explanation for why
they are one of the best bands ever, this ain't it. In fact,
it is not entirely clear who this box set was designed for.
When the original reports trickled in about an XTC box set,
rumor had it that the four disc set would have one disc of
Andy's favorites, one of Colin's favorites, one disc of live
material and one disc of outtakes and demos. Instead, this
box is chronological mishmash of live material, demos and
released versions of XTC songs.
So the set never quite tells the story it could have told,
though the outstanding liner note essay from fan Harrison
Sherwood does a good job of explaining the band's twists and
turns throughout the years. Therefore, for the uninitiated
or somewhat interested (own a couple albums or something),
this box set really isn't worth your greenbacks. What about
hardcore fans? Well, I suspect many of them have the bulk
of this material already. (I'm a step or two below the hardcore
designation and I already own almost every track on the fourth
disc). And some of the demos on this collection will likely
end up on the Fuzzy Warblings demos box that's on the
horizon.
The end result is a box set that tries to split the difference
between rarity laden and career overview, not quite doing
the full job in either department. I've basically decided
that the purpose of this box set is for Virgin to squeeze
the last few drops of blood out of the XTC stone. Why not?
Virgin fucked with XTC's career from nearly the outset, so
they might as well do it one more time. Nevertheless, this
is XTC, and so this box is teeming with terrific and/or interesting
material.
The bulk of the tracks here are either alternate unreleased
recordings or demos. Once Andy Partridge and Colin Moulding
got their own four-track recorders in the early-80's, they
made pretty damn complete demos. If the typical demo is a
mere rough image of the end product, Moulding's are in-depth
pencil sketches and Partridge's are schematic diagrams. Which
isn't to say that they don't hold any interest, but they aren't
as revealing as other artist's demos can be. I wish there
were more work tapes'. One selection on this box has
Partridge working out an embryonic version of "The Mayor
of Simpleton". Both the melody and lyrics are not quite
in recognizable form yet. This peek into the Swindonian Shed
creative process is fascinating. Of course, the demos of material
that never made XTC albums are a different matter the
more, the better.
One of the biggest scores for early XTC fans is the sundry
Barry Andrews songs that didn't make Go 2 in
the track-by-track liners, Partridge concedes that his professional
jealousy led him to make sure these fine new wave buzzers
didn't make the cut. Andrews chimes in that it was all for
the best he formed Shriekback after the second album
rebuff. Other notable early tracks include a clunky demo for
CBS of "Science Friction" (too slow), a splendid
live version of "Traffic Light Rock", the cool single
version of "This is Pop", an unused take of "Life
Begins at the Hop" and the demo version of "Making
Plans for Nigel", which drummer Terry Chambers gives
more of a disco accent.
The second disc highlights some great live material
a medley of "Into the Atom Age", "Hang on to
the Night" and "Neon Shuffle", Black Sea
rocker "Paper and Iron" and a rare performance of
"Snowman". There are a stack of unused single re-recordings
"Life Begins at the Hop", "Reel by Reel",
"When You're Near Me I Have Difficulty" and "Towers
of London" while none of these cut their best
known versions, they are all pretty cool. Coolest of all is
a Partridge work tape of the band's biggest hit in England,
"Senses Working Overtime".
Demos make up the bulk of the third disc, which makes sense,
as the band was no longer touring. Hearing how Colin Moulding
had already worked out the echoed' guitar part of "Wake
Up" makes you really appreciate his skill. For fun, try
to pretend you're Terry Chambers hearing Andy's demo of "Love
on a Farmboy's Wages" (Terry left the band he
speculated that his frenzied drumming would no longer be suitable
for XTC). For even more fun, bliss out to demos of classic
Skylarking tracks such as "Meeting Place"
and "Dear God"(a full band demo).
The fourth disc has the least in the way of riches. Only two
Dukes Of Stratosphear tracks, neither from their EP debut
what gives? There is a very cool Partridge outtake,
"The Troubles" and a fine live version of "Books
Are Burning" a fitting ending, as Dave Gregory
plays explosive guitar in what became his XTC swansong.
My initial griping aside, XTC really deserves two box sets
one to concentrate solely on the amazing legacy of
their released music and another to focus on the substantive
flotsam and jetsam that never saw the light of vinyl and aluminum.
Even in this ragged display, you can discern what makes XTC
one of the few bands that can withstand comparisons to The
Beatles without it seeming totally outlandish. Even during
the band's early caffeinated days, they had classic songwriting
skills. Their early history is greatness borne out of their
willingness to challenge the classic forms of the 60s
with more jarring forms of music, from dub to Captain Beefheart
inspired dissonance to disco to raving fury. The later years
found the band turning the difficult trick of maturing and
honing its classicism, while never complete losing touch with
their prickly and clangorous selves, while never fearing throwing
new things in the mix. With all due respect to The Fall, XTC
is the greatest post-Sex Pistols band ever.
_______________________________________________________
Clinic
Walking With Thee
(Domino)
dominorecordsco.com
Believe
the hype. Kid tested, Radiohead-approved, I tentatively approached
Clinic at my favorite record store (which, by the way, is
Laurie's Planet of Sound on the 4600 North block of Lincoln
the closest thing to the fictional Championship Vinyl
in Chicago), with the timidity of a freshman trying to ask
a major crush to a homecoming dance. I had fears of artiness
and impenetrability. OK I was aware these Liverpudlians
took the stage in surgical outfits (Clinic get it?),
which only triggered visions of Rainbow's Difficult To
Cure album this showed a sense of humor, but how
can anything that reminds me of Rainbow be any good?
But this is quite good, though Liverpool doesn't come to mind
as often as another big Brit music city, Manchester. Clinic
mixes in cool garage/psych tunesmithing with Madchesterish
dance beats, coating them with all sorts of arty whimsy, with
vocals emerging from the frothy miasma with a ghostly mystery
that suggests a gene splicing of Mark E. Smith and Thom Yorke.
Clinic casts a spell that binds, bounces and intoxicates in
equal amounts, with the periodic spine tingle thrown in
but a spine tingle of the EC Comics variety the murkiness
comes with a wink and a nod, none of that Pornography-era
Cure primal-whine crap.
What is really impressive is how the band manages to pull
out sounds from the past 35 years of pop music, primarily
blues based rock stuff, record them in a retro manner (while
the fidelity is close to hi, everything is compressed in a
manner that suggests some aural antiquing has occurred), creating
an assemblage of sounds that could only have been done here
and now. It's not exactly becoming immortal and then dying,
but to be so backward-looking and simutaneously so forward
thinking is amazing.
And the splendid songs make this more than clever soundscapes.
"Harmony" features a mix of a haunting bluesy harmonica
that fits hand in glove with the foreboding keyboard line
(some variation on Mike Oldfield's "Tubular Bells"),
while Ade Blackhorn warbles in Thom Yorkeish fashion (and
can be understood, which isn't always the case on this disc).
"Come into Our Room" uses a similar keyboard line,
and Blackhorn tremelously sings the lyrics, whilst the drummer
works a strange disco pea soup' rhythm on the hi-hat.
The title cut and "The Equaliser" both have dance
floor potential remember when you could dance to rock
music? "Walking with Thee" stomps in on a fat 4/4
beat, with overmodulated organ (shades of Inspiral Carpets)
carrying the melody, the bass line interlocking, and the song's
chorus being a mere stop-start of the song's constant rhythm
that is as dramatic as it is simple. "The Equaliser"
has some "Magic Bus" percussion, as the keyboard
is stuck on the Middle Eastern bagpipe' setting, and
the whole result is reminiscent of a tinny Happy Mondays mantra
sans the X'.
Then there's the Moroccan spy movie feel to "The Vulture",
while "Mr. Moonlight" is an insistent blues tune,
which has very little low end, the keyboards and a jazzy guitar
moving the song along, the band bringing it home at the conclusion.
"Pet Eunuch" is a screaming rocker, that puts the
moody restraint in context and either adds to or relieves
the inviting tension that snakes through the proceedings.
The more I listen, the more I hear the influence of trip hop
on a lot of what's going on here. But there's none of the
characteristic trip hop cool Clinic's world is nervous
and shaking. The album weakens a bit towards the end (though
"For the Wars" is quite a pretty and effective closer),
but the strength of the first seven or eight tracks still
makes this one of the best releases of 2002.
_______________________________________________________
Ben
Kweller
Sha Sha
(ATO)
benkweller.com
The
former leader of Radish is still not out of his teens and
remains a precocious son-of-a-gun, crafting an album that
bridges the gap between Ben Folds and Weezer. Like those acts,
Kweller is a clever bastard who pens witty lyrics. Musically,
he balances slower piano based tunes with blasts of crunchy
guitar pop.
While Fountains Of Wayne would not be an entirely accurate
comparison, Kweller shares that band's facility for careening
from softer pop to buzzing rock, and also show that his intelligence
does not mean he is incapable of tender meaningful moments
there's some heart to go along with the brains. Like
Fountains and moreso like Ben Folds, Kweller can also be a
tad glib, which gives a couple tunes an unwanted veneer of
cutesiness. This slight flaw can be tolerated amongst the
many fine moments.
"Commerce, TX" breezes with the effervescence of
prime Jason Falkner, though the song is a bit more basic and
rocking. The melody in the chorus is as inventive as any Falkner
has come up with as of late (high praise, folks), Kweller
singing a lengthy couplet where the melody ascends before
reaching a plateau and going down the scale just a bit. Kweller
rocks even more on "No Reason", the big guitars
kicking in dynamically on this slacker anthem with a fist
waving refrain.
Kweller gives musical props to indie poppers, with songs like
"Family Tree", with its twisty bass playing and
its drawling melodic variation on The Beatles' "I'm Only
Sleeping". Periodically, Kweller sings "bop bop"
in a lazy manner that fits this low key slouch of a tune.
The opening cut, one of the piano drive tunes, also has indie
charm, like a perkier Son Ambulance or a hipper Ben Folds.
When the maturity of Kweller's observations matches the wisdom
of his lyrics, the considerable nature of Kweller's potential
comes to the fore. "Trees fall/and so do men" is
just one brilliant snap from the pretty disc closer "Falling".
Rarely has self-denial seemed so appealing, as this song just
embraces you while Kweller (with his best vocal) intones "I
don't feel like I'm falling down/just say hello' to
the ground." The dramatic "Walk on Me" is a
number that old fans of Todd Rundgren and Elton John could
cotton to, though lines like "love is supposed to be
this bad/make you cry mega-ultra sad" give away the singer's
young age. Who cares when the pedal steel kicks in,
you'll wallow along.
This is the rare album to have enough cred for the college
kiddies but many veteran pop fans will appreciate a lot of
the goings on here. With youth on his side, and then some,
Kweller has a chance to be one of the most important voices
in pop-rock. This is an invigorating start.
_______________________________________________________
The
Mooney Suzuki
Electric Sweat
(Gammon)
themooneysuzuki.com
You
can't fake soul. In a world that is becoming increasingly
plasticized, corporatized and blanded beyond belief, soul
and guts and energy are needed more than ever. It's this notion
that propelled the soundtrack of O Brother Where Art Thou
to the top of the charts. Humans playing instruments and singing
and making sounds from the heart.
While the amplification and the style may be different, The
Mooney Suzuki comes from the same place. There will be some
folks who scoff at these modern garage rockers and find contrivance,
mocking their basic rock and roll as artifice. One listen
to "The Broken Heart" should be enough to dispel
such cynicism. A smoldering slab of soul, singer Sammy James
Jr. sounds like he's halfway on the Billy Jack scale to truly
exploding passionate, but in control, his voice sounds
like a cross between the MC5's Rob Younger and Jimi Hendrix.
This song is simply a Solomon Burke or Otis Redding worthy
slab o' dixie fried sadness, and when the organ hums in during
the instrumental break, you'll just sway in sympathy. One
of the best songs of the year.
The Mooney Suzuki is telling proof that one doesn't have to
simply go balls to the wall to really rock. In fact, a little
bit less can be more (a/k/a The Al Green Theory), and when
you're playing music with a blues/R & B base, deft rhythm
work means more than the ability to turn the amps up as loud
as possible. The mid-tempo "Oh Sweet Susanna" chugs
along so smoothly Augie Wilson's snare work alone is
sublime, the chorus has a slight but enduring melody, this
is laid back garage rock maybe porch rock would be
a better term.
Sometimes their R & B prowess combined with their heaviness
potential comes off like some sublime alt-universe where The
Small Faces and Humble Pie combined forces "It's
not Easy" mixes the slinky, snarky pop-R & B of the
teeny mods with a screaming guitar workout (Graham Tyler,
take a bow) in the middle it's all rock and roll to
The Mooney Suzuki, and why not, since they are all rock and
roll.
If you just want your head ripped off, just program your disc
player to the opening salvos, two songs forged in Detroit
steel but for the recording quality (recorded in the
Motor City by knob ace Jim "Diamond Jim" Diamond),
you might be able to fool friends into thinking this is some
band that opened for The MC5 and the Bob Seger System at some
Down With The Pigs rally in a park in 68. The title
cut just radiates "Kick Out The Jams" heat, though
it's more streamlined than its proto-metal influence. James
sings one of the best quatrains I've ever heard on "In
a Young Man's Mind": "In a young man's mind/it's
a simple world/there's a little room for music/and the rest
is girls". Let me tell you that this song captures both
the excitement of rock and roll and the about-to-burst sexuality
that those lines encapsulate, it's all build up and release,
controlled frenzy, it's shouting, screaming FUCK!!!
Throw in two shit hot instrumentals and the only folks who
will be immune to this puppy are either snobs ("oh, it's
not original") or pussies ("must they rock so much?").
I not only thank The Mooney Suzuki for such a great album,
but thank them in advance for the hundreds of teens who will
decide to pick up an instrument after hearing rock the way
it's meant to be played.
_______________________________________________________
Kenny
Howes and the Yeah!
Kenny Howes and the Yeah!
(Royal
Fuzz)
royalfuzz.com
It
would be a shame if this disc got lost in the cracks, as this
is Howes's most mature effort yet, and shows him adding rocking
depth to his already well established ability to pen and perform
some of the sharpest Southern power pop that I've ever heard.
If you are unfamiliar with Howes and the Yeah, let's just
say that they are the only band that could seriously challenge
The Shazam for the title of Cheap Trick of the South'.
Melodic tunes played on loud guitars with a rhythm section
in the tradition of The Move and The Who these guys
do that very well. Not that everything was big pop city
you could hear The Beatles, Todd Rundgren, The Raspberries
and others when the volume was lowered a bit.
On this album, the band takes more forays into straight rock
songs which isn't to say that they have skimped on
melodies and catchiness, but some songs clearly deviate from
typical three minute structures. And the results make me wonder
why the band hadn't showed off this side before. If anything,
this disc makes the band more relevant than ever, as the songs
are powerful not just musically, but emotionally
you can feel some of these songs, and more importantly, Howes
does.
There's the searing "Diary Queen", which comes off
like a cross between Material Issue and The Who, with concise
lyrics, a rocking performance by the band, and distinct movements
within the song that bring it to an exhilarating climax. Howes
tops this with "Strangers", which opens with a mournful
piano that is soon counterpointed by a slicing lead guitar
line (angry jangle?); while this song has its own melodic
base, it mixes the heft and power of "Layla" with
power pop. The music serves as an effective vehicle for Howes'
ruminations on why we as individuals are so alienated from
each other. Howes deploys simple two-line examples of the
contradictions that fill our lives and create distance.
Not every track spills over with fury. The mid-tempo "Down
to Earth" is a sweet track with dollops of lead guitar
the song is a Southern variation on Matthew Sweet/Cliff
Hillis tuneage, both tender and joyful. Howes slows down the
tempo even further on a cover of Kirsty MacColl's classic
(and Tracey Ullman's big hit) "They Don't Know".
By slowing the number down and taking out the bravado, the
song suggests different interpretations is the protagonist
extremely relaxed and confident in the relationship, or is
he beaten down and full of resignation, and thus half-heartedly
trying to convince himself this love is still good? I've heard
this track both ways.
Long time Howes fans should not fear. The Yeah still kicks
out some straight pop tunes that are all happiness and hooks.
"You Make Me Feel Like I'm not Crazy" proves that
when life gives you slight paranoia, look to your lover, and
turn it into sunshine. Kelly Shane's drumming is particularly
creative on this track. The single "Sheila, She"
is textbook pop writing short and sharp, stringing
together three pithy melodic ideas into one terrific whole.
And "Go There" is a great rock and roll kiss off
tune, in the mold of Cheap Trick and the Jeff Lynne edition
of The Move. Let's just say that you can really do the Brontosaurus
to it.
The only misstep on the album comes with the closer, "Few
& Far Between", which ends with an endless repetition
of the same guitar chords over and over. No variation in tempo,
no embellishment, just the repetition. This is a technique
that rarely, if ever, is effective.
However, this is another example of Kenny Howes and the Yeah
not being satisfied with cranking out the three minute pop
numbers that they have mastered a long time ago. Howes and
crew obviously understand that so many of the best rock bands
balanced light and dark sides, and the added dimension shown
on this effort makes them only more formidable.
_______________________________________________________
To
reach any other page contained in this month's update on Fufkin.com,
read the home page for the appropriate link and click on it.
You can also search the site from any page using the search
box located at the top of each page. Merely type in the word,
phrase, name of the band, recording, name of the Fufkin writer
that you are looking for or Whatever in the search box, and
then click on "Search". If you would like to e-mail
us, go to the About Us page for a list of e-mail addresses.
Go
back to the home page by clicking
here
______________________________________________________
|