Mike
Bennett Reviews:
March,
2005
Scroll
down for the latest releases by Sparkwood, Petra Haden, The
Doves, Bloc Party and The Sugarplastic
Sparkwood
Jalopy Pop
(self released)
sparkwood.com
Sugary sweet is not always the best way
to describe pop music. If sugary sweet means the aural equivalent
of sour gummy worms, well then you're probably talking about
the next Hillary Duff wannabe. Yecch! However, if sugary sweet
means something you'd fine at a good neighborhood bakery --
a wonderful eclair or...a chocolate cannoli in Little Italy
-- that's a splendid thing. This disc is a splendid slice
of sugary sweet pop.
The second Sparkwood disc comes four years after the first
one. Band leader Bart Padar has spent that time refining his
approach. In so doing, he has sacrificed some of the rock
energy exhibited on the debut, but that wasn't the essence
of Sparkwood. Instead, it was smooth and insinuating pop songs
that put Sparkwood in league with artists like Fountains Of
Wayne, Cherry Twister and The Davenports.
Sparkwood remains in that league. Padar quickly demonstrates
that he has grown over the past four years as a songwriter.
"Cruel World" is a song that shows both ambition
as a composer and a lyricist. The song's melody harkens back
to classic 50s rock and roll balladeering, and would
be suitable for swooning with a teen queen at a sock hop.
However, this pop waltz has more depth than a slow dance song.
Padar sings about a seemingly perfect love that falls apart
because the man and woman's lives were going in different
directions. While there is no brilliant wordsmithing here,
Padar is direct and economical, and the music and words mesh
perfectly, creating a maximum impact. There's even a wonderfully
beautiful instrumental break, that is almost symphonic in
its power.
Likewise, "Ready for the Day" is another pretty
and resonant number. Here, Padar fits a sing song melody over
a nimble piano part, augmented by soothing synthesizers. Indeed,
the whole song is soothing, and Padar effectively moves the
melody to make the chorus stick. This all leads to another
jawdropping instrumental break, with his battery of keyboards
painting lush sound pictures and Deborah Lutes's operatic
vocals (that's what it says in the liners) creating a substantial
atmosphere. And Michael J. Wane contributes a pithy lead guitar
figure that compliments this bittersweet song.
These stretched out songs are indicative of Padar's maturation.
By no means, however, has he abandoned the art of making happy,
perky pop songs. On "Where She Ought to Be", Padar
puts a Texas spin on the sunny songs that The Beach Boys did
in the Sunflower era. "D" sounds like 70s
AM radio pop, as if Sparkwood was competing with Gilbert O'Sullivan
to make a song that's pop-rock with a music hall/vaudeville
twist. At least it comes off that way early in the track,
when a clarinet and trombone blow whimsically. The song then
takes a detour into soaring guitars, and the wind instruments
join them. The song then gets back to its original course.
It's a trip worth taking. There is a basic rock and roll number,
in the fun "Where She Ought to Be", and songs like
"Emergency" and "Miles Away" are the best
evidence to support those comparisons to Cherry Twister and
Fountains Of Wayne.
Making a record that can be this sweet without being cloying
or annoying is a tribute to Padar's talent. Moreover, although
Padar has a limited, nasal voice (which sometimes comes close
to reminding me, in an uncomfortable way, of REO Speedwagon's
Kevin Cronin), he knows how to tailor songs that suit it well.
What more can be said, other than Sparkwood has made a superb
sophomore disc.
________________________________________________________________
Petra Haden
Petra Haden Sings: The Who Sell Out
(Bar/None)
bar-none.com
As explained in his loving liner notes,
this project started as a challenge -- Mike Watt effectively
daring Petra Haden, the accomplished vocalist and violinist
from that dog and The Rentals, to cover the entirety of The
Who's third album. Watt explains that he and his former Minuteman
bandmate (the late) d. boon, were gigantic fans of the album,
and, for whatever reason, he thought it would be fun to hear
Ms. Haden interpret the album. Watt leaves unexplained whether
the challenge included a stipulation that Haden do this project
with only the sound of her voice. Nevertheless, armed with
an eight-track recorder that Watt gave her, that's how Haden,
who was not familiar with the album, tackled the project.
If you, like Haden, are not familiar with The Who Sell
Out, let me tell you right away that Watt and boon were,
as usual, spot on in loving the album. It is also my favorite
Who album. First off, you should know that it's a concept
album. The album attempts to recreate a commercial pirate
radio station, commercials and all. The challenge for Pete
Townshend was to write a bunch of songs in a variety of styles.
He passed that test with flying colors. Second, as a result
of tackling this diversity, Townshend's burgeoning skills
blossomed as never before. In trying to write a bit of everything,
Townshend unlocked a door that led to reservoirs of melodic
and lyrical depth that he may not have opened otherwise. Compositions
like "Rael" and "Sunrise" are stunning,
and would have been great achievements for genius contemporaries
like Lennon and McCartney and Ray Davies.
And those songs were relegated to the second
side of the LP. Of course, in the pre-digital age, the radio
concept did lose a little steam when the record was turned
over, and on the last few songs, it was disposed of entirely.
This may be the only flaw in the album.
So does Haden's low-fi a capella version shed any light on
the album? Yes, it does, or at least on some of the songs.
And how does it stand on its own? Pretty darned well, I must
say. She is clearly a skilled arranger, and a wonderful vocalist.
She's fine in the mid-range, where many of these songs reside,
and when she gets a chance to move to the top of her range,
she sounds angelic. In spots, it almost sounds like The Roches
(a big compliment, in my book), as on "Odorono".
Perhaps the only song that doesn't quite fly is the best known
track on the album, "I Can See For Miles". Not that
it's an outright dud, but the original is so rhythm driven,
that Haden's "do dos" and "dits dits"
fall a wee bit short. More often, the a capella renditions
add a sheen or reveal just how good these songs are. Or, in
the case of the Speedy Keen composition "Armenia City
in the Sky", Haden shows that there is more than one
way to make a psychedelic song sound psychedelic. (OK -- that's
an empty phrase -- what I mean is, The Who version is full
of production tricks and feedback and distended horns. Haden's
good attempt at replicating that with her voice is equally,
if not more, trippy).
This is certainly the case on her stellar rendition of "Tattoo".
This classic teenage drama about two brothers who get tattoos
and face the wrath of their parents has brilliant lyrics that
are both formal and self-important, yet leavened with subtle
wit. Haden's choral rendition heightens both the seriousness
of the narrative and the underlying humor. Meanwhile, Haden's
superb pipes give the soaring melody of "Our Love Was,
Is" its proper due. Haden's effort here makes the song
her own. She doesn't quite wrest the overlooked gem "Sunrise"
from Ol' Pete, but she comes close.
There is one other song that Haden, if she doesn't steal it
from The Who, she has at least staked a claim for a share
of it. The epic "Rael", part of which formed the
basis for the subsequent "Underture" from Tommy,
sounds majestic and ethereal. Lyrically, the song is an incomprehensible
myth/sci-fi/or something else tale. Again, Haden's stellar
singing imports a seriousness to these words that fits so
well with the music, which is stirring in the verses and in
the middle eight -- my word, the melody of the middle eight
is one of the best Townshend has ever written. No offense
to Roger Daltrey, but Haden simply does this melody more justice.
I can't say that I'll play this as much as I play the original.
But I can say that in at least a couple of the instances I
noted above, when I'm listening to The Who's album, I'll be
hearing Petra Haden's version.
________________________________________________________________
The Doves
Some Cities
(Heavenly/EMI)
emimusic.info
The third Doves album does not reveal any
major changes in direction. The rock band with the warm and
inviting big sound has apparently just spent the past few
years refining their craft, listening to some soul sides,
and not resting until they had a couple fistfuls of top drawer
material. The result is perhaps the best Doves album yet.
What I find most striking, particularly on the first half
of the disc, is how successfully the band incorporates old
R & B moves into their music. They do so in a way that
puts a fresh spin on their songs, without changing the basic
ingredients that typify The Doves. The single "Black
and White Town" is a sterling example of this. Basically,
The Doves found a way to thread a 50-foot high Doves melody
with a rhythm track based on Martha and the Vandellas' "Heatwave".
The band comes perilously close to owing Holland-Dozier-Holland
royalties, playing a very very slight variation on the classic
tune, on a distorted wobbly electric piano. Thus, the band
makes this familiar music still sound a bit different and
otherworldly. This wouldn't mean much if the band didn't add
anything to it, but The Doves are more than up to the task,
coming up with a killer chorus.
On "Snowden", what would otherwise be a decent mid-tempo
pop tune gains an edge and intensity with the use of a haunting
backing vocal chorus that sounds like it came from some big
60s soul production. This both contrasts and compliments
the song, giving more heft to the tune. The song builds to
a microburst of fuzz guitar which then sends the song into
the clouds. This is a jawdropping track.
On other tracks, The Doves stay the course. This may imply
that they are coasting, but the title track, "One of
These Days" and "Walk in Fire" all sound like
potential singles with strong hooks. "Fire" is a
very simple song, perhaps comparable to some of the blues
laced material that U2 did in the late 80s, but more
lightfooted. While maybe it's not an obvious hit, this is
an incredibly accessible song, and I could see it really expanding
The Doves' audience. "Some Cities" is just a great
piece of British rock, sounding like a collaboration between
Paul Weller and The Stone Roses. The airy semi-psychedelic
pop swirl surrounds dollops of bluesy guitar licks. Meanwhile,
"One of These Days" hits upon a chill bump inducing
melody -- at its core it reminds me of one of the Jackson
5's "I Am Love". While different in many aspects,
this song shares a similar dramatic and haunting feel.
Some other nice touches include the strings on "The Storm".
This song would segue well into Electric Light Orchestra's
"Above the Clouds". And there are two powerful slow
numbers, the mournful piano piece "Shadows of Salford"
and the pretty closing track "Ambition", which wafts
from the speakers like light puffs of smoke.
One thing that is remarkable about this album is how evocative
and emotional it is, even though The Doves lyrics are, in
themselves, unremarkable. While the vocals aren't buried in
the mix, they aren't emphasized and often, only snatches of
words come through. This clearly isn't an impediment, perhaps
because the vocals are expressive, even when the lyrics aren't
memorable. The other thing that strikes me is how The Doves
are capable of the type of success gained by Coldplay, Travis
and their ilk. All of these are bands with big sounds and
melancholy vibes. What distinguishes The Doves is that their
music has much more emphasis on rhythm and has earthier roots.
I don't know why that would hurt their chances for a bigger
audience, but it does explain why I like them better than
somewhat similar British bands.
_______________________________________________________________
Bloc Party
Silent Alarm
(Wichita)
wichita-recordings.com
This British band came to prominence in
2004, with a series of singles and an opening slot for Franz
Ferdinand. The band is definitely part of the wonderful post-punk
brigade that seems to be everywhere nowadays. Unlike Franz
Ferdinand and The Futureheads, Bloc Party is more of a rock
band. These guys simply sound massive. While there are traces
of Gang Of Four in their sound, Bloc Party comes closer to
the sound of Joy Division, The Chameleons, and, dare I say
it, early U2. If you want to get a bit more contemporary,
then look to Interpol, though they don't reach for the rafters
like this band, and Idlewild, though Bloc Party hasn't reached
Idlewild's level of consistent songwriting. Or should I say,
they haven't found enough variety yet Bloc Party is
a model of consistency.
This album has some great songs on it, and the lesser cuts
tend to sound like weaker versions of the great songs. Making
up for this, in a big way, is the fact that Bloc Party is
already one of the most explosive bands on the planet. It
all starts with drummer Matt Tong. He's a perpetual motion
machine who is all crisp fills, big drum rolls and a constant
presence on the kick drum. Shit, he could probably make Train
or Matchbox 20 sound like a really rocking band. Yes, he's
that good.
Meanwhile, singer Kele Okereke and Russell Lissack form a
devastating two guitar attack. Not only can they cobble together
scratchy funk riffs like Gang Of Four, but they can lacerate
with stinging and searing leads, often lacing their leads
together in beautiful and deadly fashion. Gordon Moakes is
a great bass player, simply because he can do whatever it
takes to allow his mates to take off in all directions. Okereke
is a passionate singer, whose intensity matches the playing,
though he never gets carried away.
The first half of this disc contains about 1,000 megatons
of rock power, and almost renders the second half an afterthought
(please note that almost). The opener, "Like Eating Glass",
is what the first cut on a rocking album should be
starting with a light lead guitar and plucked bass, and then
Tong brush the hi-hat before getting the beat going. Then
the lead guitar riff gets going, and Okereke exclaims "it's
so cold in this house". This is a song that coils the
tension. Listen to the creative basslines Moakes plays while
the guitars and drums are in lockstep. Even when the tension
releases, the song doesn't explode in the first chorus, but
they instead wind things tighter. An amazing steady build,
and it's not even close to the best song on the disc.
A distinctive lead part propels "Helicopter", a
blistering critique of George Bush. From a lyrical standpoint,
Midnight Oil would be proud of the level of polemic at work
here, even though the words are pretty simple: "Just
like his dad/just like his dad/(the same mistakes)/some things
will never be different." The band throws in snatches
of melody amidst the stop and go dynamics and blitz of rhythms
and lead guitars. The "are you hoping for a miracle"
refrain is one of the strongest hooks on the album.
On "Positive Tension", Okereke sounds a bit like
Robert Smith, playing with a band that meshes Joy Division
and The Ruts and Midnight Oil. Again, the Tong/Moakes rhythm
section is massive, as everything in the song plays off the
relentless fat rhythm they play. The Gang Of Four sound comes
to the fore on "Blue Light", with great call-and-response
guitar work from Okereke and Lissack, and Tong breaking out
his disco drumming pea soup beat. This is the song that might
hook in the Franz Ferdinand fans, though it's hard to suss
out what the fuck it's about. The hook of the song is just
a staccato chord change and there's a really swell middle
eight that is melodic and supported by roaring guitar. The
pulsing "She's Hearing Voices" suggests a Joy Division
and middle period Public Image, Ltd. blend, aided by Okereke's
vocals that remind me a little bit of Johnny Lydon.
The band offers a respite on "Blue Light", which
is reminiscent of the softer side of Idlewild. The song is
a gentle piece of pop, with shiny reverberating guitars and
nice stately percussive instrumental break. The band is pretty
comfortable when the temperature is lowered, which is also
illustrated on the medium cool "This Modern Love".
The last five songs on the album are all fine, at one level
or another, though none of them seem to be as strong as what
preceded them. It may be that Bloc Party's level of intensity
is such, that a 10 song album would have been a better idea.
Either that, or as I mentioned earlier, just a little bit
more variety is needed. It would also help if it was clear
what they were being so passionate about. For example, "The
Pioneers" may be about colonialism...or our poor treatment
of the environment...or something else. It's not that have
any obligation to be U2 or The Clash and solve the world's
problems in song, but all this power would mean more if the
words had more meaning.
So this exhilarating debut is not perfect. But this band has
carved out a unique niche with its post-punk style. Just hearing
them play is a pleasure, and that fact that there are some
great songs on here makes them one of the most exciting bands
around. Let's give them some time and see how far they can
go.
_______________________________________________________________
The Sugarplastic
Will
(Tallboy)
tallboyrecords.com
Around some circles, The Sugarplastic are
just thought of as a band that sounds like XTC, yet there
is so much more to this band. From almost the get-go, The
Sugarplastic has dabbled in spectral, somewhat twee psychedelia
(for example, find a copy of their "Where Dead Bullies
Go" from what now seems like ages ago). This aspect of
the band has become more prominent and is a large part of
this fascinating disc. At the heart of this album is frontman
Ben Eshbach's unique guitar style, where he seems to play
notes in a circular fashion (I don't mean this technically,
it's how it sounds to my untrained ears). Eshbach has said
that The Monochrome Set was the initial inspiration for how
he plays, and that makes sense. Like XTC and The Monochrome
Set, The Sugarplastic have perfected a sound that mixes odd,
dissonant sounds with pure melodies.
Parts of this album have a real Alice In Wonderland,
dreamy quality. Sometimes this is due to the distortion put
on Eschabach's vocals. Other times, it's just due to the childlike
simplicity of the compositions. For example, "Underwater"
plays like a series of mantras, with almost every instrument,
from the guitar to the bass to the bells that are prominent
on the track, playing similar rhythm parts, as Eshbach sings
lines like: "Bells and chimes/a pair of paradigms/everyone
tries/to open their eyes/underwater". While the meaning
of this track is elusive, the elusiveness is actually part
of what makes this and many of the other tracks on this album
so compelling.
Other songs float in from the mist, such as "The Bodice
of a Young French Girl" and "What the Boy Said".
On "Bodice", Eshbach's delicate lead guitar playing,
doubled up by a keyboard, wafts in and keys the track. He
distorts his vocals in parts, going from his normal range
to an altered lower range. The melody heads in one direction
and then reverses itself. The song is an effective exercise
in repetition, with a wrinkle or two thrown in (like Julie
Bachman's wordless vocal interlude) to break up the ebb and
flow. This is mysterious and beguiling.
The opener "What the Boy Said" is another song that
folds parts on top of each other. Here, the initial vocals
sound like they are at the wrong speed, with a pinched, near
chipmunk-like effect. These elfin tones are offset by the
XTC-ish refrain, and there's a rocking middle-eight after
the second refrain. Which is followed by an unintelligible,
but cool, heavy lead guitar driven part. Yes, I am utterly
unable to describe this distinctive song. What I'm trying
to get across is that it has about six or seven distinctive
parts, and all of them are perfectly woven together.
It's because there are quite a few tracks
in the vein of "Bodice" and "Boy" that
this is an album that takes a few plays to fully sink in.
Only a few songs are immediately accessible. "Very Stereo"
is a classic Sugarplastic song, with Eshbach extolling the
joys of Miss Katherine (or is it Miss Catherine). This song
is played in a waltz tempo, and Eshbach counts the days until
he marries her, and counts the ways he's going to capture
her, write to her, and do many other things to her, too, I
suppose. I could count the ways that this is a conventional
psych-pop tune, and then count the ways that it still is unique.
Like Kiara Geller's spare and sympathetic coloring on the
bass, or the numerous guitar parts Eshbach plays, including
some stabbing leads, and the nifty use of dynamics that sets
up the primary guitar solo, and how he goes from that to a
more playful solo.
A little 20s style guitar antics (how about "I'm
Going to Alabamy Now" or "Flat Foot Floogie"?)
are the prelude to "Jesus Is His Name", the most
XTC-ish cut on the whole affair. This appears to be a pretty
straightforward declaration of faith, that is lumbering and
nimble at the same time, and catchy as all get out. "The
Runaround" is breezier, relying on a pulsing bass-and-drums
rhythm and sweet guitar playing by Eshbach. The chorus is
more rushed rather than loud-soft dynamics, this is
laid back/aggressive dynamics.
This is one of those albums where I keep noticing some a snatch
of words or guitar part or chord change that I hadn't focused
on before. I'm still trying to suss out what it all means.
For example, is the reference to Jesus in "French Girl"
tied to the song "Jesus Is His Name"? Are there
broader concepts here that I can't grasp? Maybe I'll figure
it out, someday. I do know that this music means something
to the folks who are playing on it. What they have created
is an album that stands out from the crowd, and it's unforgettable.
___________________________________________________________
To
reach any other page contained in this month's update on Fufkin.com,
read the home page for the appropriate link and click on it.
You can also search the site from any page using the search
box located at the top of each page. Merely type in the word,
phrase, name of the band, recording, name of the Fufkin writer
that you are looking for or Whatever in the search box, and
then click on "Search". If you would like to e-mail
us, go to the About Us page for a list of e-mail addresses.
Go
back to the home page by clicking
here
________________________________________________________________
|