James
Baumann
Reviews:
October,
2004
Scroll down for reviews of The Mendoza Line,
The Clash, The Thrills and Maplewood
The Mendoza Line
Fortune
(Bar None)
www.themendozaline.com
Never before has a band, named for mediocrity,
reached so high.
Since the first spin of Fortune, the new
disc by the Mendoza Line - so named for the .200 batting average
of Mario Mendoza and henceforth recognized as a reference
point for sheer competency - I have been head-over-heels in
love with it. Bittersweet and witty lyrics as well as hook-filled
(and occasionally twangy) melodies spill out of the band's
three songwriters. Each writer has his or her own distinct
tone and feel, yet each track is also, certainly, a Mendoza
Line song. Its cohesion comes through in their spirit and
delightful looseness. This album delivers the heart of Dylan,
the raggedness of The Replacements, and the poetry of both
and if that praise seems extravagant then you'll have to take
my word for it. Remember, I said I was in love.
Fortune leads off - like many Mendoza Line
collections seem to - with a lazy rhythm track, in this case
entitled "Fellow Travelers." Timothy Bracy sings
like a graduate of the Shane McGowen School of Elocution as
the song slowly builds with a rich choir of voices and slide
guitar. "An Architect's Eye" is another Bracy- sung
track; a fantastic bluesy shuffle with banging keyboards and
soaring guitars all accented by the backing vocals of bandmate
Shannon McArdle.
Ah, Shannon McArdle. To my ears, she is the
Mendoza Line's clean-up hitter. Her voice is reminiscent of
Lucinda Williams (though smoother, as though she's about a
thousand shots of whisky younger than Williams) and her songs
are more likely to include slide guitars, which makes her
the reason the band sometimes gets lumped in with the alt-country
crowd. "They Never Bat an Eye," a hymn-like ballad,
does nothing to diminish that practice. "Flat Feet and
Western Style" shifts back and forth between a rave-up
and a lament."
She also sings lead on the album's brightest
moment, "It's a Long Line (But It Moves Quickly)"
written by Bracy and Peter Hoffman. In it she recounts a laundry
list of bad relationships, tossing them on the scrap heap
of history with deft turns of phrase and barely-masked scorn.
And when she announces that, of all the men, "one's out
to lunch and the other one's no picnic" I closed the
polls and declared it my lyric-of-the-year.
Hoffman is the third songwriter in the band
and the songs where he sings tend to remind me of Bill Janovitz
from Buffalo Tom: a bit more straightforward rock with a more
obvious hook than other tracks. "Tiny Motions" is
the one that really gives me the Buffalo Tom feel; it does
a great job of making more from less. There is space between
the chords, but it continually moves forward, bringing the
listener along through a rolling, hook-filled chorus. "Before
I Hit the Wall" chugs with furious guitar riffing and
keyboard parts that wouldn't be out of place on a John Hughes
film soundtrack. Meanwhile, "Let's Not Talk About It"
shows he can do slow songs as well as fast.
The Mendoza Line may have a reputation as
indie-rock's loveable losers. They sort of stumbled out of
the slacker-dom of Athens, GA up to Brooklyn, followed by
stories of the occasional sloppy show and/or relationship
breakdown. But this record strongly caps a great run (2002's
Lost In Revelry is another must-own) that shows the band coming
into its own. Search this record out. You'll likely find it
at the top of my year's best-of list.
_______________________________________________________________
The Clash
London Calling 25th Anniversary Edition
(Columbia Legacy)
www.epicrecords.com/theclash/
I'm probably always going to argue that The
Clash's self-titled debut album is my favorite one from the
band: that initial burst of passion, energy, and songs is
near impossible to match. But after re-examining London Calling
I have a better understanding of why some would argue that
this is a better disc.
For The Clash, their punk spirit was still
alive for this record, but the spit and anger had grown into
an exciting mixture of a number of different musical styles
that ended up being uniquely their own. But, really, is there
anything anyone else can write that is a stronger argument
for this album's quality other than looking at the track listing.
"London Calling," "Train In Vain," "Death
Or Glory," "Lost In the Supermarket," "Rudie
Can't Fail," "Spanish Bombs," and the cover
of "Brand New Cadillac" just begins to scratch the
surface of what this album has to offer.
Columbia Legacy has cleaned up the sound
a bit and added a pair of other discs conveniently filled
with recently discovered materials. Disc Two is entitled "The
Vanilla Tapes" and contains the rehearsals and demos
the band worked up for London Calling. I'm always interested
in hearing a song come to life through earlier incarnations,
and this disc delivers that. The ragged recordings (stay on
the mic guys!) include most of the London Calling tracks as
well as a Bob Dylan cover. A track called "Working and
Waiting" would later have vocals added and become "Clampdown."
"London Calling" would get considerably faster."
We learn how "Hateful" grew from little more than
a repeated guitar riff into a fantastic song. The only thing
that would have made it better would have been if they had
captured / included any studio banter to help capture the
mood of the times or at least a 15-minute rant from Joe Strummer
about overcoming social injustice.
Also packaged is a DVD documentary entitled
The Last Testament that covers the making of the album. It
is mostly talking-head commentary, with some new footage and
other interviews from the 1999 Clash documentary Westway To
the World. The highlight of this comes as everyone recounts
the exploits of producer Guy Stevens who famously pogoed around
the studio, tossed chairs and ladders, drenched a piano in
wine, and wrestled the sound engineer - all supposedly to
improve the band's performance. Also included on the DVD is
some grainy footage of the band in the studio as well as promotional
clips for "Train In Vain," "Clampdown,"
and the title track.
All in all it's another classic package from
Columbia Legacy. The collection of material along with the
restored packaging (the 35-page booklet is excellent for reading
or browsing) is exactly the type of treatment that a landmark
record like this one deserves.
________________________________________________________________
The Thrills
Let's Bottle Bohemia
(Virgin)
www.thethrills.com
For their debut record, The Thrills went
on a quest from their native Ireland to the sunny shores of
California and came away with a delightful album that ended
up on plenty of best-of lists. But what do you do for a follow-up?
Can you discover the Holy Grail of Pop a second time?
They came close, choosing to replace some
of the lush synthesizers with a bit more guitar punch and
some of the lyrical sunny optimism with shady realities. "Saturday
Night" suggests that the night that's right for fighting
isn't always all it's cracked up to be. "Whatever Happened
to Corey Haim?" analyzes American tabloid culture. "You
Can't Fool Old Friends with Limousines" reminds us that
no one forgets your past no matter how far you run. "Our
Wated Lives" is self-explanatory. And "Faded Beauty
Queens" admits "I don't know how we ended up here."
Perhaps the most optimistic sentiment on the disc is "I
found my Rosebud." Sure, he found it. But that's a tough
loss to first go through.
To match the lyrics, the music has a bit
more of an edge, but this is still a Thrills record which
means full orchestration and hooks a'plenty. I think the band
is going to need to find a way to shake up their formula a
bit if they are worried about longevity, but what they are
doing right now still works.
________________________________________________________________
Maplewood
Indian Summer
(Tee Pee Records)
www.teepeerecords.com
Have you heard? Quiet is the new loud. The
guys in Maplewood certainly have as they offer up a pleasant
disc of tunes tailor-made for driving along the Pacific Coast
Highway with the windows down and the AM radio playing.
Maplewood is a sort of indie-all-star line
up with Mark Rozzo (Champale) and Ira Elliot (Champale, Nada
Surf) as well as Steve Koester (Punchdrunk, Koester) Craig
Schoen (Cub Country) and Jude Webre (The Places) plus guest
appearances by Alan Weatherhead (Sparklehorse). The band's
sound most resembles that of another famous musical collaboration
- Crosby, Stills, Nash, and Young. Youngsters would refer
to last year's record by The Thorns. But regardless of who
you want to compare them to (come to think of it, The Flying
Burrito Brothers wouldn't be a bad choice either) Maplewood
is all about breezy harmonies, gentle 12-string strumming,
and a hint of desert twang.
When I reflect back on the record I don't
remember individual songs or hooks quite like I do the overall
mood and feeling. This is possibly the most comfortable record
I've heard this year. But don't take that to mean I'm tagging
it as easy-listening. It's just that when the songwriting,
playing, and harmonies are this tight, it can't help but be
soothing.
There is a little sameness to the disc as
a whole - it's like the songwriters chose all the more mellow
tracks from their other bands' albums. But there's no denying
the quality of what's included.
____________________________________________________________
To
reach any other page contained in this month's update on Fufkin.com,
read the home page for the appropriate link and click on it.
You can also search the site from any page using the search
box located at the top of each page. Merely type in the word,
phrase, name of the band, recording, name of the Fufkin writer
that you are looking for or Whatever in the search box, and
then click on "Search". If you would like to e-mail
us, go to the About Us page for a list of e-mail addresses.
Go
back to the home page by clicking
here
________________________________________________________________
|